Monday, September 8, 2008

My personal pie

I grumbled about having to take Communications 111 class for my nursing degree. Not because I feel snobby about my level of communication skills. It's just that I have studied these things before during various career paths and have taught classes for almost a decade. Then there's the whole five-kids thing, which means that my available time for classes is precious and if I can get out of a general ed requirement, I will. (It worked for my other degree-in-progress.)

No luck this time around. So tonight, I had my second Oral Communications class of the semester. I can't say I loved it!!! It's a late class after what are always exhausting days at home with the kids, and sitting through a lecture in a hot classroom doesn't jump out at me as the most exciting thing ever. But tonight brought something into focus that I wanted to share.

Tonight's class focused on identity and the person we present to the world. The instructor asked us to list the many roles we identify with. Examples would be: gender, family role, job, skill set, political party, religion, etc. Then, we were asked to divide these up into relative percentages based on how important they are to us, and to create a pie chart based on these percentages.

So I wrote out my list~~not in order of importance.

Wife
Mother
Student
Follower of Jesus Christ
Future nurse practitioner
Youth leader at church
Woman
Mentor
Writer
Friend
The neighborhood mom

Obviously, I could get a lot more deep and talk about past roles I have identified with and all that stuff, but this was a quick class exercise.

I made my circle and pondered the top labels. Follower of Jesus Christ. Wife. Mother. These were the top three, and I sat there wondering how to divide them up. I drew my circle and wrote "Follower of Jesus Christ" all along the outside. It is my soul's lens. He has changed me in my other roles. I can't put Him in His own unique category apart from the others. This might sound weird to you.

Then, being a wife and mother took up a huge chunk of my pie. The next most important roles to me were that of neighborhood mom (yes, I take that role very seriously!), friend, student, future nurse practitioner, youth leader, and writer. I have opted not to include percentages here, as it's hard to be specific. Who knows what the exact numbers are? There's also overlap. My role as mother definitely spills over into the dozen or so kids that hang out near our home at any given point, and my friendships show up at church, on the internet, and in person. Church includes time with the youth that we work with after the five o'clock service. Etc.

What did become clear is that "political party" did not show up on my list.

Every four years, I get miserably stressed. I get moody. I get unfocused. I get scatterbrained. I try my best to narrow down my viewpoints into a neat political party and pick a candidate. This year, my friend Jenna asked the question, "Who's watching the primary debates?" and from that point on, I engaged with this election and began watching, reading, and taking my role as American voter very seriously again for this upcoming round. I changed my mind about how to vote in the primaries at least three times.

The truth is, I have some viewpoints which would put me at odds with some of the closest people in my life~~viewpoints, beliefs, opinions that are the opposite of my loved ones, and others that are the same. Some of my personal viewpoints diverge from the political party I would otherwise identify with. I can feel myself getting more and more lost in the whole thing and finding it hard to discuss the election without taking a stand for one side or the other and being loud and opinionated in an area~~politics~~that really doesn't strike me as a huge part of my identity at all. One might argue that it's impossible to separate oneself from politics. Probably it is, but here I blog. I am, by the way, remarkably endowed with the gift of sarcasm, but as it states in Proverbs, Discretion will protect you, and understanding will guard you... (2:11)

So this exercise showed me that I don't consider a political party to be a vital aspect of my identity. Walls have not come up between me and my friends, but being able to state this outright makes it clear to me that I don't want walls to divide us over something so unique to our individual experiences and perspectives. I don't want to feel obligated to "figure it all out" either. My own uncertainties~~the areas I cannot make into a box around myself~~are probably going to remain that way. Simply living life day to day and doing my best to be useful and loving to my brothers and sisters is challenge enough. As I attempt to communicate my perspective with others, I pray we truly can seek to understand each other and let our hearts be open.
Love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind. This is the first and greatest commandment. And the second is like it: 'Love your neighbor as yourself.' ~Mt 22:37
Even as I get ready to post this, I wonder if I am not being firm enough along certain lines...that ambiguity is terribly unfashionable in politics...that black and white is the name of the game. There are some issues I feel very black and white about, and others less so. The black and white issues are my politics. And I do believe we have an obligation to fight for the issues that matter deeply to us. But does that mean a vehement blog or article about it? Or does that mean grassroots work at the level it occurs, dealing more with the face-to-face of it all? Or both? I pray I can go forward with discretion and understanding and, as my instructor puts it, "achieve the task of communication while maintaining relationship." That is my goal and hope.

5 comments:

  1. Once again, you've hit the nail on the head of what I've been thinking lately. It's so hard to even discuss it when you don't choose up sides and buy a whole agenda, and get all "with us or against us" on issues with such complex gray areas.

    I find the only way I can deal with political discussions anymore is to stand on my own, apart from the options I've been given for teams to join and argue for.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I really like the line, "achieve the task of communication while maintaining relationship." However that's a lot easier said than done.

    ReplyDelete
  3. In my life during election time, I ask myself, "What is at stake?" And, for me at this time, I feel there is a lot. And that is what makes me passionate and outspoken. But that doesn't mean we have to agree with our candidate or party in its entirety. It is all very personal, but it depends on what you care about and what you would like to see acheived.

    I absolutely think your commentary was written with amazing eloquence and I love it. You and I have gone into great detail and discussed at great length so far what our beliefs are. And I feel that's brought us closer. I think about you very often throughout the day.

    The funniest part about it, is that I think we have the same goals and desires and love for people on the whole. Our ideas of how that is acheived is the part that is different. It has inspired me to learn more about our history, the industrial revolution, the social reform that came about in the early 1900's and how important all of those things are to our society. I've learned about the one historical record in Spain of people living in your ideal (this 50% socialism 50% libertarian) that worked.

    So, while the political issues might not be a forefront in your life, communication is. And this type of communication is good in so many ways. It allows us to understand others and it allows us to grow our world view. Great knowledge, if you ask me.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I have no issue at all with "passionate and outspoken." (I may be wrong but the tone of your statement made it seem like I was critical of "passionate and outspoken viewpoints." I hope I did not imply that.) I myself have been very passionate and outspoken about many causes! These last two years have been very transformational, as though I have an entirely different self now, and many issues that used to be important to me are no longer.

    For the record, I must say that I truly do not identify one way or the other with the Libertarian Socialists. I had no idea that was a real term when I jokingly referred to it. Maybe I *am* and I just don't know it! But I wanted to clear that up.

    I agree that we each have, as you put it (Kansas), "the same goals and desires and love for people on the whole." There is a black and white that happens in the media that I don't see happening too often in "real life." In a different comment, you stated "I would like to hear [Sarah Palin] say out loud, 'I don't care if your 11 year old daughter was brutally raped and almost killed by your 40 year old brother. Oh, and she got pregnant along the way? Oh, and she is still having reconstructive surgery to put her private parts back together? And you want her to have an abortion? Sorry, that's not allowed under my rule because I am against abortion in all cases.'

    This type of statement is misleading because it implies that the pro-life viewpoint has an indifference to a tragic situation like this one ("I don't care..." etc), that there is no compassion for that person and that the baby is the end-all-be-all for the pro-life advocate. As much as you might think this is true, it's not. It is not black and white like that. There is also no black and white reaction that women have to getting pregnant from a rape. We have been so indoctrinated with this idea that a woman immediately wants an abortion if she gets pregnant after a rape. I have counseled women who are pregnant after a rape and there is no black and white response~~not that my limited experience in this area makes me an expert by any means. I'm sure you and I would both agree that the victim of the crime needs to be dealt with compassionately and sensitively and that the perpetrator needs to be held accountable.

    Anyway, I'm really not trying to make a big point here about abortion so much as I am that these situations, responses, viewpoints, etc. are not as straightforward as we may like to think they are on either side. You and I both fiercely love that 11 year old, is my point.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Not everyone with the "pro-life view point" thinks the same way. In my opinion Sarah Palin has demonstrated as I have previously stated. And I interpret that she would react in such a way. And let me just point out that I am pro-life. That doesn't mean I can't also be pro-choice, because I am. All pro-lifers just don't have the same opinions. Sarah Palin has shown there is no exception. And I also agree that some rape victims choose to carry to full term and deliver a baby. I support them 100%. That is their choice.

    With regards to the "passionate and outspoken" comment, I'm not sure which post you are refering to, but I would never say either one of those things is a negative comment.

    ReplyDelete